← Research

Manuscript Review Benchmark

Updated from 238 reviews. The figures refresh as new reviews come in.

Across 238 manuscript reviews, ManuscriptMind flagged 4,086 issues, about 17.2 per manuscript, and rated 4.4% of them critical. Methodology is the largest category, with 1,083 issues (27% of the total).

4,086
Issues flagged
238
Manuscripts reviewed
17.2
Issues per manuscript
4.4%
Rated critical

Figure 1

Issues by category and severity

Methodology1,083
Statistics700
Data presentation629
Conclusions597
Writing553
Literature427
Reporting57
Numerical consistency40
Critical
Major
Minor
Fig. 1. Every issue raised across 238 manuscript reviews, grouped by the category it was filed under and stacked by severity. Bars are scaled to the largest category.
Show data table
CategoryCriticalMajorMinorTotal
Methodology1208151481,083
Statistics32369299700
Data presentation2268359629
Conclusions18343236597
Writing2112439553
Literature4136287427
Reporting1193757
Numerical consistency0112940

Figure 2

Mean rubric score by domain

Rigor3.17
Significance3.43
Presentation3.53
1 · weakest5 · strongest
Fig. 2. Holistic 1-5 scores across 236 scored reviews. ManuscriptMind deliberately returns no accept/reject verdict, so these three domains are the whole rubric.
Show data table
DomainMean score (of 5)
Rigor3.17
Significance3.43
Presentation3.53

Figure 3

What happened when every reference was checked

6.1%

of 1,187 references
had no matching work

Matched to an indexed work
Not reliably indexed
Partial match
No matching work found
Fig. 3. Every reference was checked against Crossref, Semantic Scholar, Europe PMC, and OpenAlex. "Not reliably indexed" covers books, guidelines, and preprints that these databases do not cover, so those are real works rather than suspect ones. Only "no matching work found" indicates a likely fabrication.
Show data table
OutcomeReferencesShare
Matched to an indexed work92178%
Not reliably indexed16914%
Partial match242.0%
No matching work found736.1%
Total checked1,187100%

Earlier figures

We record a snapshot each month. If you quoted this page before, find your number here.

SnapshotReviewsIssuesPer manuscriptCriticalTop category
November 17, 20262273,96417.54.4%Methodology
October 26, 20261933,81119.74.5%Methodology
September 29, 20261503,23921.65.0%Methodology
August 24, 2026982,15422.05.9%Methodology
July 27, 2026841,88322.46.5%Methodology

Cite this page

These numbers change as reviews accumulate, so include the date.

ManuscriptMind. Manuscript Review Benchmark. Data as of November 22, 2026. https://manuscriptmind.com/research/manuscript-review-benchmark

See where your own manuscript lands

ManuscriptMind runs the same review on your draft before you submit it. Your first review is free, no credit card.

Get a free review